About the Journal
Editorial Governance
For Authors
Peer Review
Publication Ethics
Research Integrity & Corrections
Transparency & Business
Policies & Preservation
RESEARCH & PUBLICATION SERVICES
VISITOR STATISTICS
Athena: Journal of Social, Culture and Society recognizes that artificial intelligence (AI), generative artificial intelligence, large language models (LLMs), and other automated tools are increasingly used in scholarly research, data analysis, writing, editing, and publication workflows. Athena permits responsible use of such technologies provided that their use is transparent, ethically appropriate, and subject to meaningful human oversight.
AI and automated tools may assist scholarly work, but they cannot assume responsibility for research integrity, authorship, accuracy, originality, ethical compliance, interpretation, or scholarly judgment. Human authors, reviewers, and editors remain accountable for their respective roles throughout the publication process.
Generative AI systems, chatbots, large language models, software applications, algorithms, and other automated tools must not be listed as authors or co-authors of manuscripts submitted to Athena.
Authorship requires accountability, approval of the final manuscript, responsibility for the integrity of the work, management of competing interests, and the ability to respond to questions concerning the research. Automated systems cannot satisfy these responsibilities.
Authors remain fully responsible for all content submitted to Athena, regardless of whether AI or automated technologies were used during research or manuscript preparation.
Authors are responsible for verifying:
Authors must transparently disclose substantive use of generative AI or similar automated content-generation tools in preparing a manuscript.
Disclosure is expected when AI has materially contributed to:
Routine use of tools for spelling correction, grammar correction, formatting, reference formatting, or basic language polishing normally does not require a separate generative-AI disclosure, provided that the tools do not substantively generate scholarly content.
Where disclosure is required, authors should clearly identify:
When AI, machine learning, natural language processing, computer vision, automated decision systems, or other computational technologies constitute part of the research methodology itself, their use should be described with sufficient methodological detail to allow readers to understand and evaluate the research.
Where relevant, authors should report:
Generative AI systems must not be treated as authoritative scholarly sources and should not replace original research literature, primary sources, datasets, official records, or other appropriate evidence.
Authors must independently locate, read, and verify the original scholarly sources underlying factual claims. AI-generated references, quotations, authors, article titles, journal names, DOIs, or other bibliographic information must never be included without verification against the original source.
The use of AI or automated tools is unacceptable when it results in, facilitates, or conceals research or publication misconduct. Examples include:
Athena does not apply a fixed percentage threshold to determine whether a manuscript is acceptable solely on the basis of an automated AI-writing detection score.
Automated AI-detection results may be considered as one element of editorial screening, but they do not independently establish misconduct, authorship, originality, or the extent of generative AI use. Any concern identified through automated screening must be evaluated by qualified editorial personnel using appropriate contextual and scholarly judgment.
Athena may use automated tools to assist editorial integrity screening, including similarity detection, AI-writing indicators, reference checking, or other research-integrity checks.
Where appropriate, Athena may use Turnitin as part of its manuscript-integrity screening workflow.
Automated results are treated as screening indicators rather than final determinations. Editorial personnel review and interpret relevant results before any action concerning a manuscript is taken.
Manuscripts received for peer review are confidential documents. Reviewers must protect manuscript content, unpublished findings, author information, and other confidential materials.
Reviewers must not upload confidential manuscripts or substantial portions of them to external generative AI systems for the purpose of generating peer-review reports, evaluations, recommendations, or substantive scholarly assessments.
Reviewers remain personally responsible for the originality, accuracy, objectivity, evidence, and scholarly judgment contained in their review reports.
Editors and editorial staff must protect the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts and peer-review communications.
Confidential manuscripts must not be uploaded to external generative AI systems for the purpose of generating substantive editorial assessments, peer-review evaluations, or publication decisions.
Editorial decisions must remain under human responsibility. Automated tools may assist administrative or integrity screening activities, but acceptance, revision, rejection, correction, and other substantive editorial decisions must be made or verified by qualified human editors.
If editors identify credible concerns regarding undisclosed or inappropriate use of generative AI, authors may be asked to provide clarification regarding the tools used, the extent of their use, relevant research records, original data, source materials, or other supporting information.
Editorial action will depend on the nature and seriousness of the concern. Action may include requesting clarification, disclosure, correction, revision, additional verification, rejection, or post-publication action where necessary under Athena's Publication Ethics and Corrections and Retractions policies.
| AI Tools as Authors | Not permitted |
| Substantive Generative AI Use | Must be disclosed |
| Basic Grammar / Language Correction | Normally does not require disclosure |
| AI as Scholarly Source | Not permitted |
| Author Responsibility for AI Output | Full responsibility retained by author(s) |
| Fixed AI Percentage Threshold | None |
| Automated AI Screening | May be used as an editorial screening aid |
| Human Verification of Automated Findings | Required |
| Reviewer Use of Generative AI for Assessment | Not permitted for substantive review |
| Editorial Decisions Generated by AI | Not permitted |
Published by Media Digital Publikasi Indonesia
Email: athena@mediadigitalpublikasi.com
Address: Jl. Kenari 18 No. 421, Desa/Kelurahan Kenangan, Kec. Percut Sei Tuan, Kab. Deli Serdang, Provinsi Sumatera Utara, Indonesia
Copyright © Author(s). Authors retain copyright.
Articles published in ATHENA: Journal of Social, Culture and Society are licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0) .