Review Process

EDITORIAL & REVIEW

Peer Review Process

SAGA: Journal of Technology and Information Systems applies a double-blind peer-review process to evaluate the scholarly quality, originality, methodological rigor, and relevance of manuscripts submitted for publication.

Research articles that proceed beyond initial editorial screening are normally evaluated by at least two independent reviewers with relevant subject expertise.

The review process is conducted in accordance with the journal's editorial policies and is informed by applicable guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and recognized principles of transparent and responsible scholarly publishing.

PEER REVIEW MODEL
Double-Blind Peer Review Normally Two Independent Reviewers Confidential Assessment Editor-Led Decisions

Under the double-blind model, author and reviewer identities are concealed from each other during peer review to the extent reasonably possible.

Authors must prepare anonymized manuscript files in accordance with the journal's Author Guidelines. Editors take reasonable steps to maintain anonymity; however, anonymity cannot be guaranteed in every circumstance, particularly where identity may be inferred from preprints, citations, datasets, or other publicly available information.

Peer-review reports are confidential editorial records and are not routinely published or disclosed outside the authorized editorial process.

01   DESK REVIEW & INITIAL EVALUATION

Every submitted manuscript undergoes an initial assessment by the editorial team before external peer review.

The initial assessment considers:

  • Relevance to the journal's aims and scope;
  • Basic scholarly quality and potential contribution;
  • Appropriateness of the research approach and methodology;
  • Completeness of the submission and compliance with essential manuscript requirements;
  • Apparent originality and research integrity concerns; and
  • Suitability for independent scholarly evaluation.

Manuscripts that fall outside the journal's scope or do not meet essential editorial requirements may be declined without external peer review.

The desk-review decision is communicated through the journal's editorial submission system.

02   REVIEWER SELECTION & ASSIGNMENT

Manuscripts that pass initial evaluation are assigned to independent reviewers with relevant academic or professional expertise.

Reviewers are selected based on subject knowledge, research experience, independence, and their ability to provide a constructive scholarly assessment.

The editorial team takes reasonable steps to verify reviewer suitability and to identify potentially fraudulent reviewer identities, inappropriate reviewer suggestions, or circumstances that could compromise independent evaluation.

Reviewers must disclose relevant conflicts of interest before accepting an invitation. Where a significant conflict exists, another reviewer will be considered.

Author-suggested reviewers, where permitted, are subject to independent editorial verification and are not automatically appointed.

03   INDEPENDENT PEER REVIEW

Reviewers independently evaluate the manuscript and submit evidence-based assessments and recommendations to the responsible Editor.

Reviewers are expected to provide objective, constructive, professionally respectful, and sufficiently detailed comments to support editorial assessment and author revision.

Reviewers must treat manuscripts, supplementary files, research data, and editorial correspondence as confidential materials.

Reviewers must not share, distribute, or delegate manuscript evaluation to unauthorized individuals or services.

Requirements concerning the use of generative AI and other automated systems in peer review are governed by the journal's separate Artificial Intelligence Policy.

04   REVIEW CRITERIA

Manuscripts are evaluated according to their scholarly and technical contributions. Review criteria include, where applicable:

  • Relevance to technology, computing, information systems, and the journal's scope;
  • Originality, novelty, and significance of the work;
  • Clarity of research objectives and research questions;
  • Appropriateness and rigor of the methodology;
  • Validity of experiments, analyses, models, algorithms, or system evaluations;
  • Adequacy of evidence supporting the reported findings;
  • Reproducibility and transparency of the reported methods, where applicable;
  • Quality of the results, discussion, and interpretation;
  • Consistency between objectives, methods, results, and conclusions;
  • Appropriate use of relevant scholarly references; and
  • Clarity, organization, and overall academic presentation.

Reviewers may identify ethical or research-integrity concerns for editorial consideration. Such concerns are handled under the journal's Publication Ethics and related policies.

05   EDITORIAL ASSESSMENT & DECISION

After receiving the relevant reviewer reports, the responsible Editor evaluates the recommendations together with the manuscript's scholarly merit and compliance with the journal's requirements.

Editorial decisions may include:

  • Accept: The manuscript is suitable for publication, subject to any remaining production requirements.
  • Minor Revision: Limited changes are required before further editorial consideration.
  • Major Revision: Substantial revisions are required to address important scholarly or methodological concerns.
  • Resubmit for Review: The manuscript requires substantial redevelopment and a further round of scholarly evaluation.
  • Reject: The manuscript is not suitable for publication in the journal.

Where reviewer recommendations differ significantly, or where additional expertise is needed, the Editor may seek an additional independent assessment.

Reviewer recommendations inform, but do not determine, the editorial decision.

06   AUTHOR REVISION & RESPONSE

When revision is requested, authors receive relevant reviewer comments and editorial instructions.

Authors should submit:

  • A revised manuscript addressing the requested changes;
  • A point-by-point response explaining how reviewer and editorial comments have been addressed; and
  • A reasoned explanation where a recommendation has not been adopted.

Revision requests do not guarantee subsequent acceptance.

Depending on the nature and extent of the changes, the revised manuscript may be assessed by the responsible Editor or returned to reviewers for further evaluation.

Authors must submit revisions within the timeframe communicated by the editorial team or request an extension where necessary.

07   ADDITIONAL REVIEW & REASSESSMENT

Additional review rounds may be required when substantive issues remain unresolved or when significant new material has been introduced during revision.

The Editor may invite the original reviewers or additional qualified reviewers, as appropriate.

The number of review rounds depends on the manuscript's scholarly quality, the adequacy of revisions, and the issues identified during assessment.

SAGA does not guarantee acceptance following any particular number of revision rounds.

08   FINAL EDITORIAL DECISION

The final decision to accept or reject a manuscript is made by the Editor-in-Chief or an appropriately delegated responsible Editor acting under the journal's editorial authority.

The decision considers the reviewers' assessments, the authors' responses, the quality of the final manuscript, and its overall suitability for publication.

Editors must exercise independent academic judgment. A favorable reviewer recommendation does not automatically result in acceptance.

Where a responsible Editor has a relevant conflict of interest, the manuscript must be reassigned to an appropriate independent editor.

Authors may challenge an editorial decision through the journal's established complaints and appeals mechanism.

09   PRODUCTION & PUBLICATION

Following formal acceptance, the manuscript enters the journal's production workflow.

Production activities may include:

  • Final editorial verification;
  • Copyediting and language checking;
  • Formatting and layout preparation;
  • Bibliographic and metadata verification;
  • Author proofreading;
  • DOI and publication metadata preparation; and
  • Final quality-control checks.

Articles are published according to the journal's publication schedule and production readiness.

Acceptance does not guarantee publication in a specific issue or on a specific date.

10   REVIEW & PUBLICATION TIMELINE

SAGA aims to conduct editorial assessment and peer review efficiently while maintaining appropriate scholarly standards.

Processing times vary according to reviewer availability, manuscript complexity, the extent of requested revisions, and the number of review rounds required.

Any timeframe communicated by the editorial team represents an estimate rather than a guaranteed deadline.

Editorial decisions are based on scholarly evaluation and are not guaranteed within a fixed processing period.

✓
Independent and Confidential Scholarly Evaluation

SAGA applies double-blind peer review and normally obtains assessments from at least two independent reviewers for research articles proceeding beyond editorial screening. Final publication decisions remain under independent editorial authority.