Publication Ethics

RESEARCH INTEGRITY & ETHICAL PUBLISHING

Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement

SAGA: Journal of Technology and Information Systems is committed to maintaining the integrity, reliability, transparency, and ethical standards of scholarly publishing.

The journal's publication ethics framework is informed by applicable guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing, Version 5.0, developed jointly by COPE, DOAJ, OASPA, and WAME.

This statement establishes the ethical responsibilities of authors, editors, reviewers, and the publisher. Detailed operational requirements are provided in the journal's corresponding editorial and publication policies.

CORE PRINCIPLES OF PUBLICATION ETHICS

SAGA expects all participants in scholarly publishing to uphold honesty, accountability, transparency, fairness, confidentiality, independence, and respect for the integrity of the scholarly record.

Editorial evaluation must be based on scholarly merit, methodological soundness, originality, ethical compliance, relevance to the journal's aims and scope, and contribution to scientific knowledge.

Manuscripts must be evaluated without discrimination based on nationality, ethnicity, gender, religion, disability, institutional affiliation, political beliefs, or other characteristics unrelated to scholarly quality.

01   AUTHORSHIP & CONTRIBUTORSHIP

Authorship must accurately reflect the individuals who have made substantial scholarly contributions to the research and manuscript.

  • All listed authors must approve the manuscript submitted for publication and accept appropriate responsibility for their contributions.
  • Individual contributions must be disclosed accurately and transparently.
  • Guest, gift, honorary, ghost, or otherwise misleading authorship practices are prohibited.
  • Contributors who do not qualify for authorship should be acknowledged appropriately, subject to their consent where applicable.
  • Requests to add, remove, or rearrange authors must be supported by a reasonable explanation and agreement from the affected contributors.

Authorship disputes will be evaluated fairly. Where necessary, the journal may request documentation or refer unresolved disputes to the relevant institutions for investigation.

02   ORIGINALITY & RESPONSIBLE PUBLICATION

Authors must submit scholarly work that is original, accurately reported, and appropriately acknowledges the intellectual contributions of others.

Authors must not submit substantially the same manuscript simultaneously to multiple journals. Previous dissemination, related publications, preprints, translated versions, or overlapping materials must be disclosed when relevant.

Legitimate scholarly reuse and secondary publication may be considered where properly disclosed, appropriately attributed, and consistent with the journal's editorial policies.

Authors, editors, and reviewers must not engage in citation manipulation, coercive citation, fabricated references, or practices intended primarily to distort citation metrics.

Detailed requirements concerning plagiarism, similarity screening, and text recycling are governed by the journal's separate Plagiarism and Similarity Screening Policy.

03   ALLEGATIONS OF RESEARCH & PUBLICATION MISCONDUCT

SAGA takes allegations of research and publication misconduct seriously, whether concerns arise before or after publication.

Potential misconduct may include:

  • Fabrication or falsification of research data;
  • Misleading manipulation of research images or results;
  • Plagiarism or substantial undisclosed overlap;
  • Duplicate or redundant publication;
  • Authorship or contributor misrepresentation;
  • Citation or peer-review manipulation;
  • Submission of fabricated manuscripts or involvement in paper-mill activities;
  • Misrepresentation of ethical approval, research consent, or supporting documentation;
  • Deliberate concealment of significant conflicts of interest; and
  • Other practices that compromise the integrity of scholarly communication.

Allegations will be assessed objectively, confidentially where appropriate, and proportionately to the seriousness of the concern.

The editorial team may request explanations, original research records, supporting data, authorship documentation, ethical approvals, or other relevant evidence.

Where an allegation requires investigation beyond the journal's authority or expertise, SAGA may contact the relevant institution, research-integrity office, funding body, or other competent authority.

The journal will distinguish between honest errors, unresolved concerns, and substantiated misconduct. Allegations alone do not establish wrongdoing.

04   REPORTING ETHICAL CONCERNS & PROTECTION OF REPORTERS

Authors, reviewers, readers, research institutions, and other stakeholders may report suspected publication misconduct or concerns affecting the integrity of published or submitted research.

Reports should provide sufficient information to permit an initial assessment, including relevant evidence where available.

Reports submitted anonymously may be considered when they contain credible and verifiable information. The absence of an identified reporter does not, by itself, invalidate an allegation.

SAGA will take reasonable steps to protect the confidentiality of individuals who raise concerns in good faith and will not tolerate retaliation through its editorial processes.

Confidentiality may be subject to applicable legal obligations or the requirements of a fair and appropriate investigation.

05   CONFLICTS OF INTEREST

Authors, editors, reviewers, and other individuals participating in the editorial process must disclose relationships or interests that could influence, or reasonably appear to influence, their professional judgment.

Such interests may be financial, institutional, professional, academic, personal, or otherwise relevant to the publication process.

Authors must provide an appropriate conflict-of-interest declaration, including an explicit statement when no relevant conflicts exist.

Editors and reviewers must disclose relevant conflicts before participating in the evaluation of a manuscript.

Where a significant conflict exists, the affected editor or reviewer must withdraw from the relevant editorial responsibility, and an appropriate alternative arrangement must be established.

06   ETHICAL OVERSIGHT

Research involving human participants, animals, personal information, confidential records, or other activities requiring ethical oversight must comply with applicable laws, regulations, disciplinary standards, and institutional requirements.

  • Appropriate ethical approval or exemption must be obtained where required.
  • Informed consent must be obtained where applicable.
  • Identifiable personal information must not be published without appropriate authorization or another valid ethical and legal basis.
  • Privacy, confidentiality, participant welfare, and responsible data handling must be maintained.
  • Authors must accurately report the ethical safeguards applicable to their research.

SAGA may request supporting documentation where ethical compliance requires verification.

07   DATA INTEGRITY & REPRODUCIBILITY

Authors are responsible for the integrity, accuracy, and transparent reporting of the research data, methods, software, algorithms, analyses, and findings presented in their work.

Research methods should be reported with sufficient clarity to permit meaningful scholarly evaluation and, where reasonably possible, reproducibility.

Authors should preserve relevant research records in accordance with applicable legal, institutional, disciplinary, and ethical requirements.

Supporting research data, code, and materials should be made available where ethically, legally, and practically appropriate. Legitimate restrictions must be explained through the manuscript's Data Availability Statement.

The journal may request access to supporting information when necessary to assess the reliability or integrity of reported findings.

08   EDITORIAL RESPONSIBILITIES

Editors are responsible for maintaining a fair, impartial, confidential, and academically independent editorial process.

  • Evaluate manuscripts according to scholarly merit and the journal's established criteria.
  • Protect confidential submissions and editorial communications.
  • Identify and manage relevant conflicts of interest.
  • Respond appropriately to credible ethical concerns.
  • Avoid discriminatory practices, inappropriate influence, and manipulation of publication metrics.
  • Maintain appropriate records of editorial decisions and ethical investigations.

The Editor-in-Chief has responsibility for final editorial decisions, subject to the journal's published policies and applicable legal obligations.

Detailed procedures concerning reviewer selection, double-blind peer review, manuscript revision, and editorial decisions are described in the separate Peer Review Process.

09   REVIEWER RESPONSIBILITIES

Reviewers must provide objective, constructive, evidence-based, and professionally respectful scholarly assessments.

Reviewers must maintain the confidentiality of manuscripts and related materials, disclose relevant conflicts of interest, and avoid using unpublished information for personal or professional advantage.

Reviewers must not manipulate citations, misrepresent their expertise, delegate confidential review responsibilities without editorial authorization, or otherwise compromise the integrity of the review process.

The journal's specific requirements concerning peer-review procedures and artificial intelligence are provided in the corresponding policies.

10   PUBLISHER RESPONSIBILITIES

Media Digital Publikasi Indonesia, as the publisher of SAGA, is responsible for supporting transparent, responsible, and sustainable journal publishing operations.

The publisher supports editorial independence, the implementation of publication ethics, the appropriate handling of integrity concerns, and the maintenance of the scholarly record.

The publisher must not improperly influence editorial decisions for financial, commercial, institutional, or personal advantage.

Administrative or commercial considerations must remain separate from the academic assessment of manuscripts.

11   INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY & AUTHOR RIGHTS

Authors and other contributors must respect intellectual property rights, provide appropriate attribution, and obtain necessary permissions for third-party materials included in submitted manuscripts.

Copyright ownership, publishing rights, open licensing, permitted reuse, and self-archiving are governed by SAGA's separate Copyright and Licensing Policy.

12   POST-PUBLICATION RESEARCH INTEGRITY

The journal's responsibility for research integrity continues after publication.

Credible concerns involving published research will be assessed objectively, and appropriate action will be taken when significant errors, ethical concerns, or reliability issues are identified.

The journal will seek to maintain a transparent and reliable scholarly record without silently altering or removing published research.

Procedures for corrections, expressions of concern, retractions, and related editorial notices are described in the separate Correction, Expression of Concern and Retraction Policy.

13   COMPLAINTS & APPEALS

Authors, reviewers, readers, and other stakeholders may submit complaints concerning editorial conduct, publication procedures, ethical concerns, or alleged procedural irregularities.

Authors may appeal editorial decisions when they identify substantive scientific, methodological, ethical, or procedural grounds for reconsideration.

Complaints and appeals should include a clear explanation and relevant supporting evidence where available.

The journal will assess complaints and appeals impartially and, where appropriate, arrange an independent assessment by an editor or responsible individual who was not directly involved in the disputed decision.

Submission of an appeal does not automatically reverse or suspend an editorial decision.

Ethical concerns and complaints may be submitted to the journal at saga@mediadigitalpublikasi.com .

14   EDITORIAL INDEPENDENCE & GOVERNANCE

Editorial decisions must be made independently of commercial, financial, political, institutional, or other inappropriate influence.

Journal ownership, publisher affiliation, sponsorship, institutional relationships, or other organizational interests must not determine the acceptance or rejection of scholarly manuscripts.

Manuscripts submitted by editors, editorial board members, reviewers, publisher-affiliated individuals, or other persons associated with the journal must receive appropriate independent editorial handling.

Individuals with relevant conflicts must not participate in decisions concerning their own submissions or submissions in which they have a significant competing interest.

Editorial authority and publisher responsibilities must remain clearly distinguished to protect the integrity and credibility of the publication process.

✓
Commitment to Ethical and Responsible Publishing

SAGA is committed to maintaining a fair, transparent, independent, and accountable scholarly publishing environment. Credible ethical concerns will be assessed responsibly, and appropriate action will be taken to protect the integrity of the scholarly record.