Artificial Intelligence (AI) Policy

RESPONSIBLE USE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE

Artificial Intelligence (AI) Policy

SAGA: Journal of Technology and Information Systems recognizes that artificial intelligence (AI), including generative AI and AI-assisted technologies, may support legitimate research and scholarly communication.

The journal permits responsible use of AI tools provided that their use is transparent, appropriately disclosed, and subject to meaningful human oversight.

This policy applies to authors, reviewers, editors, and other participants in the journal's scholarly publishing process.

01   GENERAL PRINCIPLES & HUMAN ACCOUNTABILITY

AI technologies may assist scholarly activities but must not replace independent human judgment, critical evaluation, or accountability.

Human authors remain responsible for the accuracy, originality, reliability, integrity, and lawful use of all material submitted for publication.

AI-generated outputs must be critically evaluated before being incorporated into research or manuscripts.

AI tools must not be represented as human contributors or used to conceal the actual origin of scholarly work.

02   AI AUTHORSHIP & CONTRIBUTOR STATUS

AI systems, chatbots, large language models, and other automated technologies cannot be listed as authors or co-authors.

Authorship requires accountable human participation, including the ability to approve the manuscript, respond to questions, disclose competing interests, and take responsibility for the published work.

Where AI tools have materially assisted the research or manuscript preparation, their use must be disclosed as required by this policy rather than represented as authorship.

03   DISCLOSURE OF GENERATIVE AI USE

Authors must disclose substantive use of generative AI or AI-assisted content generation when it materially contributes to the preparation, analysis, interpretation, or presentation of their research.

Where applicable, the disclosure should identify:

  • The name of the AI tool or system;
  • The model or version, where relevant and identifiable;
  • The purpose of its use;
  • The manuscript sections or research activities in which it was used; and
  • The nature of human review or verification performed.

Routine spelling, grammar, formatting, and non-substantive language correction do not normally require a separate AI disclosure.

However, substantive AI-assisted drafting, rewriting, synthesis, interpretation, or generation of scholarly content must be disclosed.

Disclosure must be accurate and must not imply that AI independently verified the scientific validity of the manuscript.

04   AI USED IN RESEARCH METHODS

When AI or machine learning constitutes part of the research methodology, its use must be reported as a methodological component of the study.

Depending on the research design, authors should describe relevant information such as:

  • AI model, algorithm, or system used;
  • Model version or access date, where relevant;
  • Input data, preprocessing, and configuration;
  • Prompts or interaction procedures when methodologically significant;
  • Experimental setup, evaluation metrics, and validation procedures; and
  • Known limitations affecting interpretation or reproducibility.

Methodological reporting is distinct from disclosure of AI used only to assist manuscript preparation.

Authors should provide sufficient information to permit appropriate scholarly assessment, subject to legitimate legal, ethical, privacy, or security restrictions.

05   AI-GENERATED CONTENT, DATA & RESEARCH MATERIALS

Authors must verify the accuracy and appropriateness of AI-assisted text, references, calculations, code, images, figures, and analytical outputs before submission.

AI-generated references must not be included unless the cited sources have been independently verified and genuinely support the relevant claims.

Synthetic data, simulated images, and AI-generated research materials may be used where scientifically justified, accurately identified, and appropriately documented.

Such materials must not be misrepresented as genuine observations, experimental measurements, or independently collected evidence when they are not.

AI-assisted image enhancement or transformation must not obscure, fabricate, or materially misrepresent research findings.

Authors must respect applicable copyright, privacy, confidentiality, consent, and data-protection obligations.

06   AI-DETECTION & EDITORIAL SCREENING

SAGA may use automated AI-detection or screening tools as supplementary indicators during editorial assessment.

Detection results are not considered conclusive evidence of AI authorship, undisclosed AI use, or research misconduct.

The journal does not apply an automatic rejection threshold based solely on an AI-detection percentage.

Where screening raises a credible concern, the editorial team may request clarification, supporting information, or an appropriate disclosure from the authors.

Editorial assessments must consider the available evidence and relevant context, rather than relying exclusively on automated scores.

07   AI USE BY EDITORS & REVIEWERS

Unpublished manuscripts, supplementary materials, peer-review reports, author identities, and editorial correspondence are confidential materials.

Editors and reviewers must not upload or disclose confidential submission materials to external generative AI systems without explicit authorization from the journal and appropriate confidentiality, security, and data-protection safeguards.

Reviewers must not delegate the substantive scholarly assessment of a manuscript to generative AI.

Editors must not delegate acceptance, rejection, or other final editorial decisions to AI systems.

Limited AI-assisted administrative or editorial support may be used where authorized and compatible with confidentiality requirements.

Any permitted use must remain subject to appropriate human verification and accountability.

08   NON-COMPLIANCE & EDITORIAL RESPONSE

Where potentially inappropriate or undisclosed AI use is identified, the journal may request clarification, additional disclosure, or revision.

Concerns involving fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, misrepresentation, confidentiality breaches, or other potential misconduct are handled under the journal's Publication Ethics and related policies.

The journal will distinguish between correctable disclosure omissions and substantiated research-integrity violations when determining an appropriate response.

09   AI USE DISCLOSURE STATEMENT

When disclosure is required, authors should include an Artificial Intelligence Use Statement in the manuscript's declaration section.

Example Disclosure:

During the preparation of this manuscript, the authors used [AI tool and model/version, where applicable] for [specific purpose]. The authors reviewed and verified the resulting output and take full responsibility for the manuscript's content.

The statement must accurately reflect the actual use of AI tools. Authors should not include a generic declaration that conceals material AI involvement.

AI
Responsible AI Use and Human Accountability

SAGA supports the responsible use of artificial intelligence in research and scholarly communication. AI-assisted activities must remain transparent, appropriately verified, and accountable to human researchers, reviewers, and editors.