Plagiarism Policy

RESEARCH INTEGRITY & ORIGINALITY

Plagiarism and Similarity Screening Policy

SAGA: Journal of Technology and Information Systems is committed to maintaining the originality, attribution, and integrity of published scholarly research.

The journal uses textual similarity screening as a supporting editorial assessment method. Similarity results are interpreted in context and are not treated as automatic evidence of plagiarism.

01   PLAGIARISM & UNATTRIBUTED USE

Plagiarism involves presenting another person's words, ideas, data, methods, results, or other intellectual contributions as one's own without appropriate acknowledgement.

Plagiarism may involve:

  • Copying substantial text without appropriate quotation or citation;
  • Paraphrasing another person's ideas or arguments without acknowledging the source;
  • Presenting another person's research findings, methods, algorithms, or intellectual contributions as original work;
  • Using another person's figures, tables, datasets, images, or code without appropriate attribution; and
  • Misrepresenting the provenance or original source of scholarly material.

Plagiarism is assessed according to the nature, significance, and context of the unattributed material. It is not determined solely by the amount of matching text.

02   TEXT RECYCLING & PRIOR PUBLICATIONS

Text recycling refers to the reuse of material from an author's own previously disseminated or published work.

Text recycling is not automatically equivalent to plagiarism. Its acceptability depends on the extent, location, purpose, attribution, copyright status, and scholarly context of the reused material.

Limited reuse of standard methodological descriptions or technical terminology may be acceptable where it does not misrepresent the originality of the research.

Authors must appropriately acknowledge relevant previous publications and disclose substantial overlap when necessary for editorial evaluation.

Concerns involving redundant publication, duplicate publication, or misrepresentation of research novelty are governed by the journal's Publication Ethics Policy.

03   SIMILARITY SCREENING PROCEDURE

Manuscripts submitted to SAGA may undergo textual similarity screening during editorial assessment.

The journal uses similarity-detection software, including:

Screening tools identify similarities between submitted text and available comparison sources.

A similarity report does not establish plagiarism, originality, or research misconduct by itself.

Screening results are reviewed by the editorial team when necessary.

The absence of identified matches does not guarantee that a manuscript is free from plagiarism or other integrity concerns.

04   SIMILARITY SCREENING INDICATOR

SAGA uses an overall similarity score of 15% or lower as its normal internal screening expectation.

This percentage is an editorial indicator and not an automatic acceptance or rejection threshold.

15%
Similarity Score Is Not a Plagiarism Verdict

A score above 15% does not automatically establish plagiarism. A score below 15% does not guarantee acceptable originality. Editorial assessment considers the actual matched content.

The interpretation of a similarity score may be affected by properly cited quotations, bibliographic references, standard terminology, common methodological descriptions, and other legitimate matches.

The journal does not regard any particular similarity percentage as definitive evidence of scholarly misconduct.

05   EDITORIAL ASSESSMENT OF MATCHES

When reviewing a similarity report, editors may consider:

  • The source and reliability of matched material;
  • The extent and distribution of overlapping text;
  • Whether the overlap occurs in background, methods, results, or other sections;
  • The presence and adequacy of attribution;
  • Whether matched material represents standard terminology, legitimate quotation, or inappropriate copying; and
  • Whether the overlap affects the originality, reliability, or scholarly contribution of the manuscript.

The editorial assessment may also consider relevant prior versions, including preprints, conference papers, and previously published work by the authors.

Editors may request additional information when the similarity report does not adequately explain the identified overlap.

06   AUTHOR RESPONSIBILITY FOR ORIGINALITY

Authors are responsible for ensuring that submitted manuscripts appropriately acknowledge the sources of borrowed text, ideas, data, methods, and other scholarly materials.

Authors must not intentionally conceal substantial textual overlap or misrepresent previously disseminated research as entirely new work.

When clarification is requested, authors should provide accurate explanations and relevant supporting information concerning identified similarities.

Detailed manuscript formatting and citation requirements are provided in the Author Guidelines.

07   OUTCOMES OF SIMILARITY ASSESSMENT

Depending on the nature and significance of identified overlap, the journal may:

  • Determine that the matches are legitimate and require no action;
  • Request clarification from the authors;
  • Request appropriate corrections to quotations, citations, or attribution;
  • Require revision where problematic textual overlap can be corrected;
  • Decline a manuscript when serious, substantiated plagiarism or unacceptable duplication is identified; or
  • Refer potential research misconduct for consideration under the journal's Publication Ethics Policy.

Where a concern requires further investigation, the journal will follow its applicable research-integrity procedures rather than treating a similarity report as conclusive proof.

08   CONFIDENTIALITY OF SCREENING MATERIALS

Submitted manuscripts and similarity reports are handled as confidential editorial materials, subject to the journal's applicable policies and the processing arrangements of authorized screening services.

Access to screening results should be limited to individuals involved in legitimate editorial assessment or integrity review.

Screening tools must be used in accordance with applicable confidentiality, data-protection, and service requirements.

RELATED JOURNAL POLICIES

This policy addresses plagiarism and textual similarity assessment. Related matters are governed separately:

  • Publication Ethics: Research misconduct, redundant publication, and integrity concerns.
  • Author Guidelines: Citation formatting and manuscript preparation.
  • Artificial Intelligence Policy: AI-generated content, disclosure, and responsible AI use.
  • Copyright and Licensing Policy: Third-party rights and reuse permissions.
  • Correction and Retraction Policy: Post-publication corrections and integrity notices.
✓
Originality Requires Contextual Evaluation

SAGA uses similarity screening to support editorial assessment. The journal's normal 15% screening indicator does not replace professional editorial judgment or constitute an automatic plagiarism determination.