Correction & Retraction Policies

POST-PUBLICATION INTEGRITY

Correction, Expression of Concern and Retraction Policy

SAGA: Journal of Technology and Information Systems is committed to maintaining the accuracy, reliability, transparency, and integrity of the published scholarly record.

This policy establishes the journal's procedures for issuing corrections, Expressions of Concern, retractions, and other necessary post-publication notices.

The policy is informed by applicable guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) , including the COPE Retraction Guidelines .

01   PURPOSE AND SCOPE

Post-publication editorial actions are intended to maintain the reliability of the scholarly record and ensure that readers receive accurate information about published research.

Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and retractions serve different purposes and are applied according to the nature and seriousness of the concern.

Retraction is primarily a mechanism for correcting the scholarly record, rather than a disciplinary punishment imposed on authors.

Investigations of alleged misconduct are governed separately by the journal's Publication Ethics Policy.

02   CORRECTIONS

A formal correction may be issued when an error or omission affects a published article but does not invalidate its overall findings or conclusions.

Examples include:

  • Errors in data presentation, calculations, tables, or figures that do not undermine the principal findings;
  • Incorrect or incomplete author, affiliation, funding, or acknowledgement information;
  • Incorrect references or attribution requiring a published amendment;
  • Errors in explanatory text that materially affect clarity or interpretation without invalidating the research; and
  • Other correctable inaccuracies that warrant transparent notification to readers.

Minor typographical or formatting errors that do not affect interpretation or the publication record may not require a separate formal notice.

Substantive amendments must be documented transparently rather than silently changing the published article.

03   EXPRESSION OF CONCERN

An Expression of Concern may be published when credible, substantial concerns exist about a published article but the available evidence is insufficient to determine whether correction or retraction is appropriate.

This notice may be considered when:

  • Important questions about the reliability of published findings remain unresolved;
  • A relevant institutional or formal investigation is ongoing;
  • Available evidence is inconclusive and further assessment is necessary; or
  • A substantial delay in resolving a credible concern makes it necessary to alert readers.

An Expression of Concern does not constitute a final finding of research misconduct.

When additional evidence becomes available, the journal will review whether the notice should be updated, resolved, or followed by another appropriate editorial action.

04   RETRACTIONS

Retraction may be necessary when a published article contains serious problems that substantially undermine its reliability, integrity, or ethical acceptability.

Circumstances that may warrant retraction include:

  • Unreliable findings resulting from major error, fabrication, falsification, or inappropriate data manipulation;
  • Substantial plagiarism or unacceptable duplication of previously published research;
  • Serious violations of applicable research ethics, consent, confidentiality, or participant protection requirements;
  • Compromised or manipulated peer review that materially undermines confidence in the publication;
  • Serious copyright or other legal violations that cannot be adequately resolved through correction; or
  • Other substantiated problems that render the article or its principal findings unreliable.

A finding of deliberate misconduct is not always necessary for retraction. Serious unintentional errors may also justify retraction when the findings are unreliable.

Retraction is not automatically required for every error. Where the overall findings remain reliable, a correction may be more appropriate.

05   POST-PUBLICATION ASSESSMENT

Concerns about published articles will be assessed objectively and proportionately, considering the available evidence and potential impact on the scholarly record.

The editorial team may request relevant explanations, documentation, or independent expert advice.

Authors will normally be given a reasonable opportunity to respond to substantive concerns before a final decision, except where exceptional circumstances justify another approach.

Allegations requiring formal investigation will be handled under the journal's Publication Ethics Policy and applicable COPE guidance.

06   EDITORIAL RESPONSIBILITY

Decisions concerning corrections, Expressions of Concern, and retractions are made by the responsible editorial authority based on the evidence and the integrity of the scholarly record.

The publisher, Media Digital Publikasi Indonesia , supports the technical publication and dissemination of post-publication notices while respecting editorial independence.

Where a responsible editor has a conflict of interest, the matter must be assigned to an appropriately independent editorial authority.

07   PUBLICATION OF EDITORIAL NOTICES

Formal post-publication notices must be clearly identifiable, appropriately documented, and accessible to readers.

Each notice should, where applicable:

  • Identify the type of editorial action, such as Correction, Expression of Concern, or Retraction;
  • Clearly identify the affected article using its title, authors, citation details, and DOI where available;
  • Explain the reason for the action in factual, proportionate, and objective language;
  • Identify the issuing editorial authority or responsible party, where appropriate;
  • Be linked to the affected article, with a reciprocal link from the article record;
  • Be made freely accessible without a subscription or payment barrier;
  • Include an identifiable publication date; and
  • Be assigned a persistent identifier, such as a DOI, where supported by the journal's publishing workflow.

Where technically supported, the journal will update relevant article metadata and DOI records to reflect the post-publication action.

Formal notices should be published without unnecessary delay once the appropriate editorial decision has been reached.

08   VERSION OF RECORD & ARTICLE STATUS

The published Version of Record must be maintained transparently.

Where a formal correction is issued, the journal should retain an identifiable record of the amendment and link the correction to the affected article.

A retracted article will normally remain publicly accessible and clearly marked as retracted.

The article's landing page and available full-text versions should clearly indicate the retraction status and direct readers to the retraction notice.

Published articles must not be silently deleted or replaced to conceal a correction or retraction.

09   EXCEPTIONAL CONTENT REMOVAL

Removal of published content is considered only in exceptional circumstances where continued public availability would create substantial legal, ethical, privacy, confidentiality, or safety risks.

Where removal is necessary, the journal will seek to retain an appropriate bibliographic record or public notice explaining the content's status, to the extent legally permissible.

Content removal is distinct from retraction and must not be used merely to avoid public disclosure of an editorial error or integrity concern.

10   REPORTING POST-PUBLICATION CONCERNS

Readers, researchers, authors, and other interested parties may report credible concerns regarding published articles to the journal's editorial office.

Reports should identify the relevant article and provide sufficient information to explain the concern.

Concerns may be sent to: saga@mediadigitalpublikasi.com

The journal will assess reports according to their substance and supporting evidence.

Detailed misconduct investigation and complaint-handling procedures are governed by the journal's relevant separate policies.

RELATED JOURNAL POLICIES

This policy governs the form, purpose, publication, and preservation of post-publication notices.

The journal's Publication Ethics Policy governs broader research-integrity concerns, allegations of misconduct, and related investigation procedures.

The Plagiarism and Similarity Screening Policy governs plagiarism assessment and textual similarity screening.

Copyright, licensing, and digital preservation requirements are governed by their respective policies.

✓
Protecting the Scholarly Record

SAGA applies corrections, Expressions of Concern, and retractions according to the nature and seriousness of post-publication concerns, with emphasis on transparency, proportionality, and preservation of the scholarly record.