Review Process
Peer Review Process
Apollo: Journal of Tourism and Business applies a rigorous peer-review process to maintain the quality, validity, originality, and academic integrity of published articles.
All research manuscripts submitted to the journal undergo an initial editorial assessment followed, where appropriate, by independent peer review. The journal applies a Double-Anonymized Peer Review process, in which the identities of the authors are concealed from the reviewers and the identities of the reviewers are concealed from the authors.
Manuscripts that proceed to peer review are normally evaluated by a minimum of two independent reviewers with expertise relevant to the subject of the manuscript.
Peer Review Workflow
Manuscripts that are clearly outside the journal's scope, substantially deficient in academic quality, fail to comply with essential submission requirements, or present significant ethical concerns may be declined without external peer review.
Authors are therefore expected to prepare manuscripts in a manner that does not reveal their identities within the anonymized manuscript file used for peer review.
Possible decisions may include:
- Accept Submission;
- Revisions Required / Minor Revision;
- Resubmit for Review / Major Revision; or
- Decline Submission.
Review Criteria
Reviewers are generally requested to consider the following aspects:
- Relevance to the journal's focus and scope;
- Originality and significance of the research;
- Clarity of the research problem and objectives;
- Adequacy of the theoretical or conceptual framework;
- Appropriateness and rigor of the methodology;
- Reliability and adequacy of data analysis;
- Quality of results and their interpretation;
- Depth and relevance of the discussion;
- Consistency between objectives, results, and conclusions;
- Contribution to existing knowledge or professional practice;
- Quality and relevance of scholarly references;
- Research and publication ethics; and
- Overall clarity and academic presentation.
Review Timeline
The journal seeks to conduct the peer-review process efficiently while maintaining appropriate academic standards. Reviewers are normally requested to complete an individual review assignment within approximately four weeks.
The actual time required to reach an editorial decision may vary depending on reviewer availability, the complexity of the manuscript, the number of revision rounds required, and the responsiveness of the authors.
Accordingly, the stated review period should be understood as a target rather than a guarantee of acceptance or publication within a specific period.
Reviewer Independence and Conflict of Interest
Reviewers must disclose any relationship or interest that could reasonably affect their impartiality. Reviewers should decline an invitation when they have a financial, professional, institutional, collaborative, personal, or other conflict that may compromise an independent assessment.
Reviewers must evaluate manuscripts objectively and must not request unnecessary citations for the purpose of increasing their own citation counts or those of particular authors, journals, or institutions.
Confidentiality
Manuscripts submitted for peer review are confidential documents. Reviewers must not disclose, distribute, reproduce, or use unpublished information contained in a manuscript for personal, academic, commercial, or other purposes without appropriate authorization.
Reviewer reports and communications associated with the peer-review process are also treated as confidential editorial records.
Submissions from Editors and Editorial Board Members
Editors and Editorial Board members are not prohibited from submitting manuscripts to Apollo: Journal of Tourism and Business. However, they must not participate in the editorial evaluation, reviewer selection, peer review, or publication decision concerning their own manuscripts.
Such submissions must be assigned to another qualified editor and processed independently under the journal's standard peer-review procedures to avoid actual or perceived conflicts of interest.
The final decision on publication rests with the responsible editor. Decisions are based on scholarly merit, relevance to the journal, research integrity, peer-review reports, and compliance with the journal's editorial and ethical policies. Acceptance is never guaranteed solely on the basis of reviewer recommendations.