Publication Ethics

Pyramid: Journal of Architectural Research, Modeling, Infrastructure, and Modern Design is committed to the integrity of the scholarly record. This policy describes the ethical responsibilities of authors, editors, reviewers, and the publisher, and explains how the journal handles concerns raised before or after publication.

1. Responsibilities of Authors

  • Accurate reporting. Describe the methods, evidence, findings, and limitations accurately. Fabrication, falsification, and misleading manipulation of data, images, drawings, or models are prohibited. If a material error is discovered in a submitted or published article, inform the Editorial Office promptly and cooperate in resolving it.
  • Originality and attribution. Credit the sources of ideas, text, data, photographs, architectural drawings, models, and other materials. Submit the manuscript to one journal at a time. Disclose related publications, preprints, and substantial overlap at submission. If several manuscripts draw on the same project or dataset, cite the related work and explain the distinct contribution of the submission. See the Plagiarism Policy for similarity screening and the treatment of prior or overlapping work.
  • Authorship and declarations. Ensure that all listed authors meet the journal's authorship criteria, approve the submission and author order, and accept responsibility for the work. Consult the Editorial Office before adding, removing, or reordering authors after submission. Follow the Author Guidelines for author contributions, funding, competing interests, and data availability.
  • AI-assisted work. Disclose applicable uses of AI in manuscript preparation and research in accordance with AI Ethics and Procedure. Authors remain responsible for verifying the accuracy and integrity of material they submit.
  • Third-party material. Identify material governed by separate rights and obtain permission where required. See Copyright & Licensing for the treatment of third-party material in published articles.

2. Research Ethics, Consent, and Privacy

For studies involving human participants or identifiable personal information, authors must obtain approval from a competent research ethics body before starting the study when ethics review is required. Report the approving body and the approval reference where issued. If the study was formally exempted, explain the basis for the exemption and provide documentation to the editors. Where a research ethics body is unavailable, explain the circumstances and document adherence to applicable ethical standards, including the Declaration of Helsinki where relevant.

Explain how informed consent was obtained where required and how personal or confidential information was protected. When photographs, quotations, case descriptions, or other materials may identify a participant, obtain consent for publication and include a statement in the article confirming that it was obtained.

3. Responsibilities of Editors, Reviewers, and the Publisher

  • Editors. Evaluate submissions fairly on scholarly merit, relevance to the journal's scope, and research integrity. Protect confidential submission information, disclose relevant competing interests, and recuse themselves from handling or deciding a manuscript when a conflict could affect their judgment. Assign the submission to an editor without that conflict. Editorial evaluation must remain independent of discrimination, external pressure, publication fees, and waiver decisions.
  • Reviewers. Accept assignments within their expertise and disclose relevant conflicts of interest. Provide timely, respectful, and evidence-based feedback. Protect confidential materials and refrain from using unpublished information for personal advantage. Report suspected irregularities privately to the handling editor. See the Peer Review Process for review procedures and AI Ethics and Procedure for restrictions on AI use.
  • Publisher. Media Digital Publikasi Indonesia supports editorial independence, safeguards confidential publishing records, and provides operational support for resolving ethics cases and maintaining the scholarly record. The journal's editors retain authority over decisions on individual manuscripts.

4. Reporting and Handling Suspected Misconduct

Authors, reviewers, readers, and other parties may report suspected research or publication misconduct before or after publication to the Editorial Office. Provide the submission ID, article title, or DOI where available, describe the concern, and include supporting evidence. The journal considers reports from whistleblowers, including anonymous reports that contain enough verifiable information. The journal handles the reporter's identity confidentially and discloses it only when necessary to resolve the matter or meet applicable obligations.

  1. Initial assessment. The Editorial Office records the report and acknowledges receipt when contact details are available. An editor without a relevant conflict assesses the information and may pause processing of the submission while the concern is evaluated.
  2. Review of the evidence. The editor may request records, seek independent advice, and give the parties concerned an opportunity to respond where appropriate. When investigation requires access or authority beyond the journal's remit, the journal may refer the matter to a relevant research institution or other responsible body.
  3. Outcome. The journal documents its decision and communicates the outcome as confidentiality permits. Actions affecting published articles follow the Correction & Retraction Policies.

5. Complaints and Appeals

For complaints about journal conduct or procedures, or for appeals by authors concerning an editorial decision or process, see the Complaints and Appeals Policy. Reports of suspected research or publication misconduct follow Section 4 of this policy.

6. Post-Publication Discussion

Readers may send evidence-based comments or questions about a published article to the Editorial Office. Identify the article and explain the point for discussion. The editors assess the comments and may invite a response from the authors. If the matter warrants a formal notice, the journal follows its Correction & Retraction Policies.