Complaints and Appeals Policy

Pyramid: Journal of Architectural Research, Modeling, Infrastructure, and Modern Design accepts complaints about its editorial and publishing activities and considers appeals from authors concerning editorial decisions or procedures.

1. Complaints and Editorial Appeals

  • Complaints. Authors, reviewers, readers, and other parties may raise concerns about the journal, its staff, its editorial board, or its publisher. Examples include failure to follow a published policy, inappropriate conduct, unreasonable delays, or an unmanaged conflict of interest.
  • Editorial appeals. Authors may request reconsideration of an editorial decision or procedure by identifying a material factual error, a significant procedural irregularity, or a relevant conflict of interest. An appeal should explain how the issue could have affected the outcome and provide supporting evidence.

Allegations of research or publication misconduct are handled under Publication Ethics. Any formal action affecting a published article follows the Correction & Retraction Policies.

2. How to Submit a Complaint or Appeal

Email the Editorial Office at pyramid@mediadigitalpublikasi.com. Use Complaint or Editorial Appeal in the subject line. Include:

  • The manuscript ID, article title, or DOI, where applicable.
  • A description of the issue and the outcome or action requested.
  • Relevant dates, correspondence, or other supporting evidence.
  • Contact details if you wish to receive an acknowledgment and outcome.

The journal may assess an anonymous complaint when it contains enough verifiable information. Authors submitting an appeal should identify the decision or procedure they are challenging.

3. Assessment and Impartial Review

  1. Acknowledgment and initial assessment. The Editorial Office records the submission, acknowledges receipt when contact details are available, and identifies the applicable policy and review route.
  2. Assignment. The matter is assigned to a qualified person who was not involved in the conduct or decision under review and has no relevant conflict of interest. If it concerns the Editor-in-Chief, the publisher arranges an impartial assessment. If it concerns the publisher, it is referred to an assessor independent of the publisher.
  3. Review of the evidence. The assessor may seek clarification, invite a response from the parties concerned, or obtain independent advice. If assessment requires substantial additional time, the journal informs the person who raised the matter when contact details are available.

4. Outcomes and Further Consideration

A complaint may result in clarification, correction of a procedural error, or another appropriate administrative action. An appeal may result in the original decision being upheld or the manuscript being returned for fresh editorial assessment. Any subsequent manuscript decision is made under the Peer Review Process.

The journal communicates the outcome and its reasons in writing to the extent confidentiality permits. A request for further consideration should identify a material issue that remains unresolved or provide significant new evidence.

5. Confidentiality and Fair Treatment

The journal keeps a restricted record of the submission, assessment, and outcome. Information is shared only as needed to assess or resolve the matter or to meet applicable obligations. Reviewer anonymity and personal information are protected. Raising a concern in good faith will not result in retaliation or unfavorable editorial treatment.