Editorial Governance & Independence

Pyramid: Journal of Architectural Research, Modeling, Infrastructure, and Modern Design assigns responsibility for scholarly evaluation and manuscript decisions to its editors. This policy defines their authority, their relationship with the publisher, and the safeguards used to protect independent editorial judgment.

1. Editorial Roles and Authority

  • Editor-in-Chief. Leads the journal's editorial direction, oversees its scholarly standards and the consistent application of its policies, and assigns editorial responsibilities to qualified editors.
  • Handling editor. Manages the assigned manuscript and exercises the authority described in the Peer Review Process. After external review, the journal's editors make the final decision on acceptance or rejection at the Editorial Meeting.
  • Editorial Board. Provides scholarly expertise and advises on the journal's scope, standards, and editorial policies. Board members exercise manuscript-level decision-making authority only when formally assigned an editorial role for the submission.

The journal maintains the names, institutional affiliations, and roles of its editors and board members on the Editorial Team page.

2. Editorial Independence and Publisher Responsibilities

Media Digital Publikasi Indonesia, the journal's publisher, provides administrative, technical, and production support. The publisher handles operational and legal matters. Scholarly evaluation and decisions on individual submissions are the responsibility of the journal's editors.

Editors assess manuscripts on scholarly merit, relevance to the journal's scope, and research integrity. Author identity, affiliation, nationality, commercial interests, sponsorship, advertising, or external pressure must not influence the assessment.

Editors responsible for decisions on a manuscript are excluded from billing and waiver decisions for that manuscript. Ability to pay and waiver status have no bearing on editorial evaluation. See Author Fees for charges and waiver procedures.

3. Editorial Conflicts of Interest

Editors must disclose relationships or interests that could reasonably call their impartiality into question. An editor with a relevant conflict must recuse themselves from handling, deliberation, and decision-making on the affected submission. The journal reassigns the manuscript to a qualified editor without the conflict and documents the reassignment.

Submissions by the Editor-in-Chief, another editor, or an editorial board member follow the same assessment and peer-review requirements as comparable submissions. A qualified editor who is independent of the submitting author handles the manuscript. The submitting editor or board member has no access to its confidential editorial deliberations and takes no part in reviewer selection or the publication decision.

4. Accountability and Governance Concerns

The Editor-in-Chief oversees the consistent application of editorial policies. The journal maintains confidential records of editorial assignments, recusals, and decisions, and updates its public roster when appointments or affiliations change.

Concerns about editorial conduct, conflicts of interest, or improper influence may be reported to the Editorial Office. The Publication Ethics policy governs complaints, appeals, and allegations of misconduct, including how concerns involving the Editor-in-Chief or publisher are referred for independent assessment.